How to choose the right private boat charter in St Maarten & St Martin
There is no single “best” private boat charter in St Maarten.
The right choice depends on your group, budget, where you are staying, how much time you have, and what you actually want the day to feel like.
Some visitors want:
- a relaxed half-day around the St Martin coastline
- snorkeling and swimming
- a full-day trip to Anguilla
- a more destination-focused day in St Barts
- extra space and comfort
- or simply an easy private boat day without crowds or complicated planning
- The best charter is usually the one that matches those priorities properly — not necessarily the biggest, fastest or most expensive boat.
This guide explains the main choices and what usually works best for different types of visitors.
• Private charters only • Carefully selected local captains • Honest, tailored recommendations • Simple booking with deposit
What to compare before choosing a private charter
For most visitors, choosing the best private boat charter comes down to five things:
- duration — half-day, full-day or sunset
- destination — St Martin, Anguilla or St Barts
- group — couples, families, friends or mixed ages
- comfort — seating, shade, space and boat style
- budget — what you actually want to spend on the experience
A half-day around St Martin often works best for visitors wanting something simple and flexible.
A full-day charter usually makes more sense if the boat day is going to be one of the main experiences of your trip.
Anguilla is particularly popular for beaches, swimming and relaxed full-day charters, while St Barts tends to suit visitors looking for a more destination-focused day.
The boat itself matters, but matching the boat, route and pace to your group usually matters more.
There isn't one best boat — there is a best fit
Boat photos make it easy to assume that choosing a private charter is mainly about finding the nicest-looking boat.
In practice, several other things often matter more:
- where the boat departs from
- how much time you want on the water
- where you want to go
- how active or relaxed your group is
- how much shade and seating you need
- whether anyone is nervous about boating
- and how much you want to spend
A smaller boat on the right route can create a much better day than a larger, more expensive boat that does not suit your group.
That is why we usually recommend choosing the experience first and the specific boat second.
Which type of private charter suits your trip?
Half-day private charter
Best for:
- shorter stays
- swimming and snorkeling
- families
- first-time visitors
- keeping the day simple
Typical feel:
Relaxed, flexible and easy to fit into a holiday.
Typical duration:
Around 3–4 hours.
Full-day private charter
Best for:
- making the boat day a major part of your trip
- Anguilla
- multiple swimming or beach stops
lunch ashore - groups wanting more time and flexibility
Typical feel:
Complete, relaxed and much less restricted by time.
Typical duration:
Around 6–7 hours.
Sunset cruises
Best for:
- couples
- celebrations
- shorter experiences
- visitors who don’t want a full day on the water
Typical feel:
Simple, scenic and relaxed.
Typical duration:
Around 2–3 hours.
Premium comfort-focused charter
Best for:
- special occasions
- larger groups
- guests prioritising space
- comfortable seating and shade
- a more refined onboard experience
Typical feel:
Spacious, comfortable and relaxed.
St Martin, Anguilla or St Barts?
Stay around St Martin
Usually suits:
- half-day charters
- families
- snorkeling
- shorter travel times
- visitors wanting flexibility
Typical feel:
Easygoing, varied and flexible.
Choose Anguilla
Usually suits:
- full-day charters
- beach lovers
- couples and families
- swimming
- relaxed lunch stops
- visitors wanting a classic Caribbean boat day
Typical feel:
Beautiful, beach-focused and relaxed.
Choose St Barts
Usually suits:
- destination-focused days
- restaurants
- Gustavia
- stylish beach clubs
- visitors comfortable with a longer day
Typical feel:
Scenic, energetic and more destination-focused.
None is automatically better. The right destination depends on what you want the day to revolve around.
What matters most when choosing the boat?
Space and seating
Enough comfortable seating for your group often matters more than simply choosing the longest boat.
Shade
Particularly important for children, older guests and anyone planning a full day on the water.
Boarding and movement
Easy access in and out of the boat can make a significant difference for mixed-age groups or less confident guests.
Boat style
Speedboats, centre consoles, power cats and sailing catamarans create noticeably different experiences.
Route and departure point
The right departure can reduce unnecessary travel and make the beginning and end of the day much easier.
Budget
Spend where it changes the experience for your group rather than automatically paying for the largest boat available.
What usually works best for different groups?
Couples
Half-day charters, sunset cruises and relaxed full-day Anguilla trips often work particularly well.
Families
Comfort, shade, easy boarding and realistic travel times usually matter more than maximising the itinerary.
Mixed-age groups
Look for enough space and flexibility for swimmers, non-swimmers, children and older guests to enjoy the same day differently.
Older or cautious guests
Calmer routes, comfortable seating, shade and realistic pacing should usually take priority over speed or distance.
Groups of friends
Full-day charters often work well when the group wants swimming, music, lunch and enough space to enjoy the boat socially.
Departure point matters more than many visitors expect
The best boat is not always the one departing from the most obvious marina.
Where you are staying and where you want to go can make a meaningful difference to:
- road travel before the charter
- time spent on the water
- route planning
- convenience
- and how relaxed the beginning and end of the day feel
Departures are available from different areas around St Martin / St Maarten, including Simpson Bay, Cole Bay, Marigot, Nettle Bay, Anse Marcel and Philipsburg, with some boats also able to arrange pickup from Grand Case.
We normally take your accommodation and intended route into account before recommending an option.
The cheapest charter is not always the best value
Private charter prices can vary considerably between boats.
But comparing price alone can be misleading because different options may vary in:
- duration
- fuel and route
- capacity
- onboard inclusions
- space and comfort
- departure point
- and additional destination or customs costs
Paying more does not automatically create a better day.
Equally, choosing the cheapest option can be poor value if the boat, departure point or itinerary does not suit your group.
The useful comparison is what you are getting for the type of day you actually want.
Why choosing from dozens of boats isn't always helpful
Many private charter options look remarkably similar online.
Photos and specifications can tell you:
- the boat size
- capacity
- departure point
- and what is included
But they do not always tell you whether that particular option actually suits your group.
Small differences in:
- layout
- comfort
- captain and crew
- style
- route
- departure location
- pacing
- and availability
can significantly change the experience.
EXPLR.SX works with a small network of local operators rather than asking visitors to compare dozens of listings themselves.
Tell us your group, date and what kind of day you want, and we can help narrow the options down to what genuinely makes sense.
Local insight
Visitors often spend a lot of time comparing boats before deciding what they actually want to do.
We would usually reverse that process.
Decide first:
- how long you want to be out
- whether you want St Martin, Anguilla or St Barts
- how active or relaxed the day should feel
- what your group needs to be comfortable
- and roughly what you want to spend
Once those things are clear, choosing the right boat becomes considerably easier.
The best charter is usually the boat you stop thinking about once the day begins.
If everyone is comfortable, the route feels natural and the group is enjoying the water, beaches and time together, the boat is doing exactly what it should.
Frequently asked questions
What is the best private boat charter in St Maarten?
There is no single best boat for every group. The right option depends on your group size, destination, budget, preferred duration, departure point and how active or relaxed you want the day to feel.
Is a half-day or full-day charter better?
Half-day charters work well for shorter coastal experiences, swimming and snorkeling. Full-day charters usually make more sense for Anguilla, longer itineraries, lunch stops and visitors who want the boat day to become a major part of their trip.
Is Anguilla or St Barts better by private boat?
Anguilla generally suits visitors prioritising beaches, swimming and relaxed Caribbean pacing. St Barts tends to suit visitors more interested in restaurants, Gustavia, beach clubs and a destination-focused day.
Do I need a large boat?
Not necessarily. Space, seating, shade, layout and route usually matter more than length alone. A smaller well-matched boat can be a better choice than a larger option your group does not need.
How much does a private boat charter cost?
Prices vary depending on duration, boat, route, capacity and destination. Half-day coastal charters generally cost less than full-day or inter-island experiences, while premium boats and longer routes cost more.
Can I choose the exact boat?
Where possible, yes. However, if you are unsure which option suits your group, we can recommend available boats based on your requirements rather than asking you to choose from specifications alone.
Which departure point should I choose?
Usually the one that works best for where you are staying and where you want to go. The most convenient departure can reduce road travel, unnecessary boating time and day-of logistics.
How far in advance should I book?
Availability varies throughout the year. Booking earlier gives you more choice, particularly for popular dates, larger groups and specific boats, although last-minute options are sometimes possible.
Related charter experiences
Half-day private charters
→ Shorter private experiences with time to swim, relax, and explore the coastline.
Full-day private charters
→ The most popular option for a complete day on the water.
Sunset cruises
→ Relaxed evening experiences with drinks and sunset views.
Anguilla private charters
→ Clear water, beach stops, and one of the Caribbean’s most popular island day trips.
St Barts private charters
→ Premium island experiences combining boating, restaurants, and time ashore.
Not sure which charter fits your trip?
Tell us your date, group size, where you’re staying and what kind of day you have in mind.
We can help narrow down the most suitable options based on your group, route, comfort level, budget and availability.
You do not need to know which boat to choose before contacting us.
What guests say about booking with EXPLR.SX
Real feedback from guests who trusted EXPLR.SX to plan their time in St Martin & St Maarten — from private boat charters to island day trips.
- Verified Guest
- Verified Guest
- Verified Guest
- Verified Guest
- Verified Guest
- Verified Guest
Related guides
Most guests have similar questions before booking.
You may also find these guides useful:
→ Understand typical prices, what affects the cost and what you are actually paying for.
→ Compare the two most common charter lengths and decide how much time you really need.
→ Choose the most practical starting point based on where you’re staying and where you want to go.
→ Decide what kind of pace and atmosphere will suit your group best.
→ Why comfort, atmosphere, layout and pacing often matter more than luxury branding.
Based on the island. Here to help.
Based in St Martin / St Maarten
Speak to someone who knows the boats
Flexible help before and after booking
EXPLR.SX is based in St Martin / St Maarten and works with a small network of trusted local operators. We match each enquiry with the most suitable private charter option based on your group, route, comfort level, and availability.
